How Long Does Rice Pudding Last

How Long Does Rice Pudding Last?

Sharing is caring!

How long does rice pudding last? Rice pudding is a dish made from rice together with water, milk, vanilla, raisins, and a sprinkle of cinnamon.

It can be served as a dessert combined with sugar.

Rice pudding differs depending on the recipe, preparation method, ingredients, and the chef.

Recipes containing ingredients like milk, cream, egg, and sugar can result in the consumption of too many calories

Sadly, these ingredients give rice pudding the perfect feel, taste, and look it should have.

So, how long does rice pudding last in the fridge?

Rice pudding will last for a maximum of 3 to 5 days, in the fridge at peak quality before going bad if you store it properly in the right conditions necessary in the refrigerator.

After cooking, allow it to cool and store in the fridge inside an airtight container.

Prepared pudding can even last 1 week in the refrigerator, while dried pudding will last for months past its expiration date.

Dried pudding lasts long because it is protected from moisture.

Shell life of rice pudding varies depending on type, packaging, storage method, and thickening agent used.

Vanilla and chocolate pudding can last 3 to 4 weeks past the expiration date when properly stored in the refrigerator and if unopened.

Once opened, dry pudding and fresh homemade pudding will last 5 – 7 days in the refrigerator.


How Long Does Rice Pudding Last After Opening?

Once opened, remove the entire contents from the package, transfer it to an airtight container and refrigerate.

Be sure it is consumed within 3 days when it is of the best quality. Nevertheless, it can last up to 5 days.


How Long Does Rice Pudding Take To Set?

It will take nothing less than 50 minutes for rice pudding to set totally, to get the right consistency (like that of yogurt).

As it cools, it thickens more, so when ready to eat, pour in a little milk to loosen it a bit.

How to set pudding; when the pudding is ready, bring it down even if it looks soupy, it will thicken as it cools.

Try not to be tempted to overcook it, else it will be stiff after cooling.

If after cooling it does not thicken, add 3 tbs of cornstarch and mix with little milk.

It will thicken and fix a light pudding, making it set well.

In order to get a firm pudding with no lumps, always stir while it is cooking till the milk has been absorbed.

Also, be cautious of the quantity of milk used, the rice should be equivalent to the milk in order to absorb it.

Too much milk will make it runny and too much rice will result in lumps. Balance the recipe.


How Long Does Rice Pudding Last In The Freezer?

Rice pudding does not necessarily need freezing

This is because it will collect moisture through condensation, and thawing will affect the consistency and texture.

However, freezing rice pudding will make it last for 3 months in good condition, it may last longer than 3 months but after a while, it will begin to decline.

Peak quality and taste are within 3 months.

When ready to use, do not thaw on the counter because leaving it out for too long will cause spoilage.

Thaw instead in the fridge overnight or use the microwave, oven, or stovetop to defrost it.

To make freezing a lot easier, allow pudding to first cool to room temperature, then portion it out into freezer bags or airtight containers.

Be sure to label and date them because foods sometimes lose recognition when they become frozen.

The date will help you keep track of how long it is stored to avoid cases of eating spoiled pudding.

Portioning it will prevent waste and make it easier to reheat and consume the exact amount.

Freezing, thawing, and refreezing are not recommended.

Before you store, ensure the bag is sealed tightly to prevent the entrance of air or moisture.

For perfect freezing results, use a milk substitute as an ingredient.

Milk does not let rice pudding freeze well.

Also, exclude the toppings when freezing.

Rice pudding that is to be stored long-term can have the toppings added only when ready to serve and consume.

Lastly, raisins are an exemption to a properly frozen rice pudding.

To achieve a good freeze, cook without raisins and only add them when reheating.


How Do You Know If Rice Pudding Is Bad?

The first sign you should be wary of is when pudding becomes watery and separates from the main ingredients.

It becomes worse when there is an appearance of mold, bitter taste, and dark coloration on the surface.

The sense organs are very efficient in telling if food is bad or not judging from appearance, color, flavor, texture, smell, and taste.

Homemade puddings that have no artificial ingredients or preservatives should be discarded after 5 days in the refrigerator and 2 months in the freezer.


How Long Does Rice Pudding Take To Thicken?

Stir pudding constantly as it cooks on low heat until a bubble breaks.

Then transfer to a bowl and allow it to cool. Next, refrigerate for about 6 hours. Rice pudding will thicken the more it sits in the fridge.

If it is still looking thin, it means it did not cook well long enough.

All you need do is pour it into the saucepan, heat again, and add a mixture of cornstarch and cold water, a little at a time until it thickens.

Then re-refrigerate.

When rice pudding is cooked on the stovetop, it is more creamy.

Though it may adhere too much to the base of the pot due to sugar and requires constant stirring.

While baking will make it thicker.

There are sometimes mistakes are made in measurement and preparation.

When too much milk is added and when milk is boiled first, rice pudding will find it hard to get a smooth, thick consistency.

Too much salt will make your pudding too thick and hard.

The consistency of pudding depends so highly on the ingredients and amount.

So don’t rush.


How Long Does Rice Pudding Last Outside The Fridge?

Rice Pudding will last only 3 hours outside the fridge with a maximum of 4 hours.

Anything more than 2 hours is becoming risky due to bacteria growth that thrives at room temperature, especially in hot rooms.

When rice pudding cools off and it’s left out for long,

Bacteria will produce toxins that will cause a lot of harm to the body when taken.

The ideal time is 2 hours due to perishable ingredients, but a cooler temperature will keep it longer.

Different types of pudding also have a time span.

Bread pudding has a maximum of 2 hours and jello pudding can keep for a maximum of 3 hours.

Anything longer than these is not recommended.

It is best refrigerated as soon as it cools off,

This is because milk and eggs are the most vulnerable ingredient

And extreme care should be taken because they are selective of temperature.


How Long Is Rice Pudding Good For After Expiration Date?

It can still safely stay for 3 to 4 months past the expiration date so long it has been properly stored and no damages to the package.

Rice Pudding past its expiration date can still be eaten so long it shows no signs of spoilage.

The expiration date in the package is only an estimate of how long the product will remain of good quality.

Your senses are good judges of spoilt or healthy rice pudding.



Can I Leave Rice Pudding Overnight?

If the package recommends refrigeration, it is advisable you heed. Do not leave it sitting out overnight.

Some store-bought puddings are left in the fridge and some on the shelf.

The ones displayed in the fridge must be kept in the fridge till the end.

While the ones displayed on the shelf can be kept on the counter overnight.

Once opened, even shelf-bought puddings must be refrigerated.

Rice pudding can be left refrigerated overnight and even for as long as 4 – 5 days.

When ready to eat, reheat it.

The best way to reheat it on the stovetop or in the oven.

For stovetop, Pour in a pan, add 2 – 3 tbs of milk or cream and reheat on medium heat. Stir as it reheats.

Do not reheat more than once.

To avoid the occasion of reheating too many times,

Store in portions so that when you take a portion out, you reheat and consume it entirely.

To reheat in the oven, warm in the oven for 20 minutes or microwave for a few minutes till it becomes hot.

It can be eaten warm or cool after refrigerating for a while to chill it.


How To Store Rice Pudding?

To store, wrap with plastic wrap to reduce any risk of air penetrating. Then place it in an airtight container and seal the lid.

Label and date and refrigerate or freeze.

Refrigeration will keep it safe for 3 to 5 days and freezing will last it 3 months. When ready to eat, thaw in the fridge overnight or microwave.

Remember to let it cool first before storing it in the freezer or refrigerating.

Proper storage condition demands that rice pudding should not be left out at room temperature for more than 4 hours.

Store Dry puddings, especially in a cool and dry place with a steady temperature.

Changes in temperature will lead to condensation and moisture which will, in turn, lead to mold growth.

Store rice pudding in containers that will reduce exposure to light, air, and fluctuating temperature.



Rice pudding is a hearty meal enjoyed by kids and adults alike.

It offers nutrients and vitamins as well as minerals.

This article has provided in detail the preparation methods, storage methods, what to expect as well as life span.

So go out there, get your ingredients ready, and make a warm bowl of rice pudding, perfect for the cold weather.

There are different types of rice and the best for rice pudding is the medium-grain white rice or risotto rice.

The medium grain white rice stands the advantage of giving off soft but not mushy results.

Risotto rice is good as well but uses more amount of time and liquid to cook.

Other rice includes;

Short grain rice is equally soft, Long grain rice is either too firm or mushy depending on how long it is cooked.

It does not have a neutral texture, Brown rice is too firm for rice pudding.

It’s best you go for medium-grain white rice.

Remember, how long does rice pudding last?


Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *