how long do butter tarts last

How Long Do Butter Tarts Last?

Sharing is caring!

riesstHow long do butter tarts last? A Butter tart is a type of small dessert tart highly regarded in Canadian cuisine.

The sweet is generally made up of a filling of butter, egg, syrup, and sugar, baked in a flaky pastry shell until the filling is semi-solid with a crunchy top.

Butter tarts are different from butter pudding or butter pie.


So, how long do butter tarts last in the fridge?

Butter Tarts can be stored in an airtight container for up to 5 days in the fridge. If kept Refrigerated, you can bring them to room temperature before serving or eat them cold,

However, it is best served at room temperature.


How Long Can You Keep Butter Tarts Past The Expiration Date?

The expiration date on the packages indicates the date that the butter tart should be consumed in order to ensure that it meets the expected high-quality standards.

After the printed date, the butter tart is still safe to eat for up to a month

If unopened in the fridge, up to 2 weeks after it is opened and for 6 to 9 months if kept frozen.

The quality of your tarts may decline and you may notice a change in flavor or texture.


Can You Freeze Butter Tarts?

Yes, Butter tarts happen to be among the treat that freezes well

So you can make them ahead of the holidays to lessen the workload during that busy time.

You can also give out your frozen butter tarts as a gift to loved ones when they are returning after the holidays.


Are Butter Tarts A Canadian Thing?

A butter tart is typically a Canadian dessert.

This is because the earliest published recipe for a butter tart dating back to 1900 is from Barrie.


Can Butter Tarts Go Bad?

Although Butter tarts don’t spoil as quickly as other dairy product, it still goes bad.

The salted varieties are more resistant to bacterial growth, but after a while, they will begin to lose their best texture.

Do not let your butter tarts go rancid before consuming them.


What Temperature Do You Bake Butter Tarts At?

Bake the butter tarts at 190 degrees Celsius (350 degrees Fahrenheit) for 20 to 25 minutes.

Once baked, bring them out of the oven and cool them for 10 minutes before removing them from the muffin cups.


Can You Freeze Butter Tarts Filling?

Yes, you can freeze the uncooked butter tart filling for another time.

Keep your butter tart filling in the freezer for up to 3 months till you’re ready to use it.


Best Substitutes For Butter Tarts pan

1. Pie Pans

In the absence of a tart pan, a pie pan is considered to be the best for baking tarts.

A lot of people often get confused between a tart and a pie, this means that a pie pan would be great for baking tarts.

Before baking tarts in a pie pan, you must understand and take charge of the difference between them.

Firstly, a pie pan consists of smooth and sloped smooth edges instead of the fluted edges in a tart pan.

This feature may not be necessarily important, but it helps in bringing out a better shape to the tart.

Secondly, a pie pan is primarily made of ceramic or glass.

in contrast, the material of a tart pan consists of metal. Because of these features, the baking time of tarts in both cases would be different,

So you need to adjust the time accordingly.

Lastly, the bottom of a tart pan is lofted-out, which is not s with a pie pan

2. Quiche Pans

A quiche pan is also known to be the best alternative because they are incredibly similar pans with just a few-dimensional differences.

3. Springform Pans

Springform pans are readily available to bake tarts, but their bottoms cannot be lifted out,

So you will need parchment paper which would help pull out the pastry from the pan after it has been baked.

The mechanism of this pan is slightly different from other pans.

Make the tarts on the springform pans and produce them in other plates since their bottom can be easily separated from the sides.


What Does Vinegar Do In Butter Tarts?

The butter tart filling is so wonderfully sweet, Apple cider vinegar is added to help balance it out for a full-bodied, tangy, rustic flavor.

The vinegar is also added to the pastry to provide a tender, flaky crust by slightly inhibiting gluten development.


10 Best Types Of Butter Tarts

1. Pecan Whisky Butter Tarts

Pecan whiskey butter tarts are pretty crimped pastries filled with sticky, dripping filling, albeit, perfectly spiked and studded with pecans.

2. Anna Olson’s Pecan Butter Tarts

Anna Olson’s butter pastries are a classic Canadian dessert.

While this recipe uses pecans, you are free to use other additions in place of the pecans such as walnut pieces, and raisins, or leave the butter pastries plain.

With Anna Olson’s butter pastries squares, you can easily enjoy your

3. Signature Butter Tart Squares

With Anna Olson’s butter pastries squares, you can easily enjoy your distinct Canadian flavors without the fuss.

4. Chocolate Bottom Butter Tarts

Add more fun to the classic tarts by baking a crumbly, chocolatey base with your favorite sweet, gooey filling still there and also topped with a chocolate drizzle.

5. Butter tart cheesecake

Whether you are purely a pecan fan or pro-raisins,

Impress your loved ones with an incredibly indulgent cheesecake, topped with a sticky, caramel butter tart filling.

6. Butter Tart Cinnamon Buns

Baked into a warm, doughy cinnamon roll,

Butter tart cinnamon buns provide all the gooey goodness you know and love about butter pastries.

7. Butter Tart Coffee Cake

This is a moist cake topped with a perfectly gooey butter tart.

8. Apple Pie Butter Tarts

These sweet tarts are flavored with warm spices like nutmeg and cinnamon, making them extra irresistible.

9. Baklava Butter Tart Bake

Baklava butter tart bake is a tasty dessert that brings together your two favorite desserts in one gooey, flaky pan,

Filled with plump raisins and crunchy walnuts.

10. Butter Tart Ice Cream

This is a splendid treat that tastes just like your favorite tart because of the sweet, buttery pecan swirls and pieces of butter pies in it.


What’s The Best Way To Store Butter Tarts?

Your butter tart should be stored in an airtight container and kept frozen.

This is the best way to store your butter tart because it lasts for months unlike the 2 days duration at room temperature or 5 days in the fridge.

Do not forget to bring them to room temperature before serving.


Why Are My Butter Tarts Soggy?

Your butter pa can become soggy and soft if you used room temperature or melted butter in making them.

If you want your pies firm, crispy, and flaky cold butter is the trick to get it.


How Do You Store Pastry Tarts?

Store your pastry tarts for 2 days at room temperature or 4 days refrigerated.

Pastries with cream fillings will keep for about three hours at room temperature or for five days refrigerated.


How To Tell If Butter Tarts Have Gone Bad

When butter pies go bad, they can get rigid and brittle, which makes them unpleasant to eat.

An unpleasant smell also accompanies a bad butter tart.

The taste and color of the butter tart will change from the original state.

To ensure your butter pastries don’t go rancid early, store them correctly and their shelf life would be extended.


What Do Butter Tarts Taste Like?

Butter pastries have a similar taste to pecan pie without pecans or French Canadian sugar pie.


What Do Butter Tarts Smell Like?

Butter pastries smell like plump juicy raisins, are buttery, and have a hint of brown sugar.



Butter tarts with their flaky pastry tart are considered one of Canada’s quintessential treats.

The sweet-tart is made up of a filling of sugar, butter, syrup, and egg, baked in a pastry shell until the filling turns semi-solid with a crunchy top.

They last longer than other dairy food, but they should be stored correctly to avoid them turning quicker than expected.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *